Week Five Prompts

-



   





E-book only books, which are increasingly popular (especially in the romance genre) see little to no reviews in professional publications unless they have a big name author, and then still it’s usually only RT Reviews or other genre heavy publications. How does this affect collection development? 




Look over the reviews- do you feel they are both reliable? How likely would you be to buy this book for your library?
  


How do these reviews make you feel about the possibility of adding Angela’s Ashes to your collection?




Do you think it’s fair that one type of book is reviewed to death and other types of books get little to no coverage? How does this affect a library’s collection? And how do you feel about review sources that won’t print negative content? Do you think that’s appropriate? If you buy for your library, how often do you use reviews to make your decisions? If not, how do you feel about reviews for personal reading, and what are some of your favorite review sources?




     According to my limited understanding of the publishing industry, I don’t think fairness enters into it very much. Of course, it isn’t “fair” that some books receive little to no attention and others receive more than they deserve or need. Collection development and readers’ access to titles are limited by this factor. But, with so many self-published books, and so many titles to choose from and shrinking budgets, decisions must be made based on information grounded in evidence and educated opinion. Whether the NYT Bestseller List is real or inflated or even completely rigged, doesn’t change the fact that many readers look to it to find their next book. With regard to reviews that do not offer negative content, my feeling is that it’s a commercial, not a review, if it fails to mention any weaknesses in the material. Negative content can be very useful information to have. By reading a wide range of reviews that incorporate different points of view and content, it can be factored into an informed decision. Unfortunately, most librarians do not have the free time to vet a book so extensively! For my personal reading, reviews can impact my choices. If it’s a genre I know well, and a reviewer complaint resonates with my own preferences, I take that into account. I enjoy using Goodreads; I rely upon it heavily. I used to read Amazon reviews, but don’t so much anymore. Goodreads is for books, so the time I spend there is time well spent if I’m looking for a book to read. Amazon can be distracting because it offers so many other products.

 

 










Comments

  1. Erin CataldiFebruary 12, 2018 at 8:58 AM

    Great prompt response - full points

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ricketikiFebruary 12, 2018 at 9:18 AM

      Thanks! I've wasted a lot of time on formatting this entry. For some reason I can't get it the appear on the blog the way it does in the composition area. I went a bit OCD on this one!

      Delete
  2. UnknownFebruary 12, 2018 at 2:03 PM

    I love the way you laid this out! It made it so much more easy and enjoyable to see your responses. The pictures are really cute. I'm a Goodreads girl, too.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Personal Reading Profile

-
Image
Bibliophile: ( noun)  a person who collects, or has a great love of books. Personal Reading Profile I have loved reading all my life. The first word I recall reading is cat. I enjoy reading for the sake of reading. I use it for gathering information, engaging in immersive experiences in fiction, and delving into  non-fiction topics and histories with biographies, large sweeping histories and detailed specific topics of history. I also enjoy reading cultural commentary, feminist theory, intellectually challenging scholarly work, literary fiction, trashy time travel romance, good time travel, science fiction (not hard), speculative science fiction, some fantasy, newspapers (present day and vintage), Twitter, just about anything. But because my leisure time is limited, when I devote energy to a book, it has to be exactly the reading experience I’m seeking. My reading tastes are somewhat eclectic. To create my personal reading profile, I began by writin
Read more

Suspense Annotation: Origin: A Novel, by Dan Brown

-
Image
Author: Dan Brown     Title : Origin: A Novel Genre : Suspense Publication Date : 2017 Number of Pages : 461 Geographical Setting : Spain Time Period : Contemporary Series : Robert Langdon #5 Plot Summary : Harvard professor of symbology and religious iconography Robert Langdon (of the Da Vinci Code) travels to the Guggenheim museum in Spain at the behest of former student and controversial tech billionaire Edmond Kirsch to observe his presentation of a scientific discovery that he claims will change the world. When Kirsch is murdered before the eyes of the watching world, Langdon and Kirsch’s colleague, museum director Ambra Vida, with the assistance of an AI program created by Kirsch named Winston, are plunged into a race to crack Kirsch’s password to launch the presentation with the hopes that whoever killed him and is pursuing them will be stopped. In one frantic night the duo evades the threats of a mysterious assassin, and race to cr
Read more

Week 12 Prompt: Nonfiction Matrix Annotation- On Tyranny by Timothy Snyder

-
Image
For your prompt this week, please complete the Readers' Advisory Matrix, found on the last page of the reading title "RA Guide to Nonfiction" in the Canvas files, about a non-fiction book you have read. If you have not read a non-fiction book recently, feel free to use some of the techniques on how to "read" a book in five minutes such as Mary Chelton's handouts or any others we have covered to get a feel for a non-fiction book. I look forward to reading these! Author : Timothy Snyder Title : On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons From the Twentieth Century Publication date : 2017 Number of pages : 126 Geographic setting : N/A Time period : 20 th and 21 st century Subject headings : Despotism. History, Modern—20 th century. Political ethics. Democracy—United States. Political culture—United States. Type : Book Series notes : N/A Book Summary : An essay divided into twenty sections on lessons from past episodes in hi
Read more

YA Annotation: Akata Witch by Nnedi Okorofor

-
Image
Author: Nnedi Okorafor Title: Akata Witch #1 Genre: YA, Fantasy Publication Date: 2011 Number of Pages: 349 Geographical Setting: Nigeria Time Period: Contemporary Series: Akata Witch Plot Summary:   Sunny is an 12 year old African-American girl, born to Nigerian immigrants, who navigates the world with a few distinct disadvantages that are compounded when her family relocates back to Nigeria: she must deal with albinism in a culture that stereotypes people like her with pale skin, yellow hair and hazel eyes as evil juju practitioners, and she is an American who speaks with a funny accent. At school she is bullied, at home her father’s disappointment that she is a girl is evident. Kids at school call her an Akata, a slur, which means bush animal, or a black American or foreign born black person. After stumbling into her first vision trance that terrifies her with images of an apocalyptic future, Sunny accidentally sets her hair on fire gazing to
Read more

Special Topics Paper: Indigenous Futurisms

-
Image
“Indigenous Futurisms: The Transformative Potential of Science Fiction’s ‘What If’ Appeal” Click Here For Full Paper (This paper has been reorganized for the blog) Science Fiction is an intellectual genre (comprised of multiple subgenres) that asks the question, “what if?”; this is the core of its appeal (Rosenberg, 1982, p.173). Science Fiction, or “SF”, “posits worlds and technologies which could exist. Science rather than magic, drives these speculative tales, and the science must be accurate and true…” (Saricks, 2009, p.245). Also known as Speculative and Visionary [1] Fiction, despite its history of male dominated creators and audiences [2] , and it’s “saturation” with “race thinking” of its particular time, the genre is “fertile” terrain for creators who question the status quo (Carrington,2016, p.2, Ertung, 2011, p.77, Saricks, 2009, p.246). From Feminist Science Fiction writers in the 1970s, to Cyberpunk [3] in the 1980s and early ‘90s (Pat Cadigan, Synners) to Afro
Read more

Book Club

-
Image
"So, I guess I'm out of the book club?" - Ben, LOST, "A Tale of Two Cities" On LOST (one my favorite TV shows) the mysterious "Others" had a book club, and it was no different than any other book club held by people who are not the descendants of a secretive hippie scientific initiative and a crew of random true believers recruited by a megalomanic engaged in exploiting a supernatural island and terrorizing plane crash survivors. According to Lostpedia, The " book club " is an informal group of  Others  who get together periodically to discuss a  book  that was selected by the meeting's host. §    Members included:  Juliet ,  Amelia ,  Adam , and four  Others background cast , three of  whom appeared in later episodes. §    Ben  didn't attend at least one meeting hosted by Juliet. Members of the "Others" on LOST have a book club Click on the video to see how tense a discussion of Stephen King's Carrie
Read more

Hello

-
Hello, my name is Ricke Elaine Ballard Gritten. I am currently a student at IUPUI working towards a Masters in Library Science. I enjoy cult television and movies, books and travel. I am a mother of two girls and am husbanded by Kevin, and act as steward to two cats, Hermione and Bandit. The purpose of this blog is to post weekly  assignments, reflections and reviews required for LIS-S 524 Adult Reader's Advisory. To explore other examples of graduate course work, please visit my Wordpress site, https://ricketiki.com .
Read more

Week Thirteen Prompt

-
Image
Week Thirteen Prompt Though this week's group of "genres" all seem very different, they all have in common the fact that many people don't feel that they are legitimate literary choices and libraries shouldn't be spending money on them or promoting them to adults. The common belief is that adults still don't or shouldn't read that stuff. How can we as librarians, work to ensure that we are able to serve adults who enjoy YA literature or graphic novels? Or should we? I can't wait to read your thoughts on this. Thanks! When applied to any material that doesn’t pose an imminent threat of danger, such as an enchanted spell book that once opened will unleash a hell dimension on earth, the words “shouldn’t read” are not in my vocabulary.  That is not to say that I don’t hold opinions on various titles or genres, in some cases very negative opinions and judgments, but it is not my place as a librarian to impose those views on a patron.
Read more

Science Fiction Annotation: The Jane Austen Project by Kathleen A. Flynn

-
Image
Annotation  Author : Kathleen A. Flynn Title : The Jane Austen Project Genre : Science Fiction>Time Travel Publication Date : 2017 Number of Pages : 373 Geographical Setting : England Time Period : Semi-distant future, Georgian England (1815) Series : N/A (Though this could easily be turned into a series.) Plot Summary : Due to global warming, the future is a place where all food is vegan by necessity, vast numbers of species are extinct and Venice is only a memory, and, oh by the way, the secret to time travel is discovered. The latest mission to the past aims to retrieve Austen’s last novel, once thought unfinished, to find out what illness caused Austen’s death and to obtain missing correspondence sought by scholars. The two-person team is comprised of an Austen obsessed American doctor, Rachel, and a British literature scholar and trained improvisational actor Liam. Upon arrival in 1815, the plan is to insinuate themselves into the circle of Austen’s favor
Read more

Week 16 Prompt Response

-
Image
"How have reading and books changed since you were a child, for you specifically?" Reflecting on Reading and Me Me Me: Eugen Spiro During my childhood reading was an escape and a refuge and a venue for learning, and eventually an act of identity creation. In elementary school, I read voraciously about dinosaurs and went to church on Sundays with my grandfather and read the Bible. Later, in about third grade, I identified conflicting narratives and took the first steps to be an atheist. (Science won, but I still love a good story.) In fifth grade, I read  A Wrinkle in Time  and identified with Meg when I was bullied and lost my father to emphysema.  Found on Pinterest In the 90’s, I read Christopher Hitchens and learned how to view the world oppositionally and critically, to be assertive and confident to express opinions contradictory to received thought, to reject authority and mock sacred cows. (Like Mother Theresa, what a bish!) I got so go
Read more